Carlisle Real Estate Search

Carlisle 5 Bedroom Properties for Sale

Our website features the best real estate search for 5 bedroom properties available in Carlisle and surrounding areas. It is the only site you will ever need! It is easy-to-use and updated by the official REALTOR®’s database every 15 minutes. 

You can save searches, and get daily email alerts of new listings, price changes, sold data, and market reports. Our Interactive Map Search allows you to view properties on a map or refine your search by drawing the boundaries around the area you desire.

Curious about what’s happening in the Carlisle real estate market? Sign up for a  Carlisle Real Estate Market Report to see what’s active, under contract, and sold!

Considering selling or refinancing your home? Get an INSTANT property valuation now!

Newest Carlisle 5 Bedroom Properties for Sale

$630,000
5 Beds 3 Baths
Ever thought about living on a golf course? Now is your chance! Welcome to this stunning 5-bedroom, 3-full bath home situated on the 6th hole of Mayapple Golf Course. This spacious and timeless beauty is bathed in natural light from large windows and provides a warm and inviting atmosphere, perfect for both relaxation and gatherings. Upon entering you will notice the beautiful hardwood floors and 9ft ceilings throughout the main level which consists of a large living room with crown molding; the dining room has a tray ceiling, double crown molding and wainscoting; an oversized family room with a wood burning fire place that also has the gas line already in place for an easy transition if desired, open to the breakfast nook and kitchen with SS appliances, granite countertops and real cherry wood cabinets. Rounding out the main floor is a large bedroom with tons of natural light and access to the back deck, a full bathroom and laundry room. Step out of the French door from the family room onto a two-tiered deck with a retractable awning and enjoy the beautifully landscaped back yard with mature trees and lush greenery creating a serene backdrop. Upstairs you will find a generous primary bedroom with two walk-in closets, an en suite bath with a jetted tub, separate shower and double sinks; plus three good sized bedrooms along with another full BA. Additionally, there is a partially finished basement along with enormous storage space, 9 ft ceilings, gas furnace w/dehumidifier, gas hot water heater and radon system.

58 Derbyshire Dr, Carlisle

Listing courtesy of Coldwell Banker Realty. Contact: (717) 761-4800

$925,000
5 Beds 5 Baths
Located just steps away from the Yellow Breeches Creek, this one owner home on a 2.9 acre lot has been lovingly maintained and upgraded. This home offers five spacious bedrooms and four and a half baths. The heart of the home is the custom Lloyd Martin kitchen, featuring a massive island, leathered quartzite countertops and full height backsplash, custom solid wood cabinets, and a deep farm sink. Culinary enthusiasts will revel in the top-of-the-line Dacor appliance package, including a steam oven and a 6-burner range with griddle, while hidden appliances and ample storage drawers maintain the kitchen’s sleek aesthetic. The adjacent family room offers a gas fireplace and Klipsch Home Theatre. Just off the breakfast nook, you'll find the all-season room that provides an additional 500+ sqft of entertaining space. This room includes custom LaCatina accordion doors that open wide to let the outside in. This room features a cozy wood-burning fireplace, a built-in Beef Eater grill with pizza oven, and a Fire Magic hood, making it perfect for cooking and entertaining year-round. From here, you can step out onto the beautifully landscaped lot and paver patio, an ideal setting for outdoor gatherings and enjoying nature. Downstairs, the finished walk-out basement offers approximately 1100 sq feet of additional living space. This basement is an entertainer's paradise with LVP floors, a custom bar, a full kitchen, a carpeted home theatre room with built-ins, and a full bathroom. Upstairs, the second floor holds a massive primary suite, complete with custom cabinetry, custom built in wardrobes with accessory storage, built in headboard with shelving, walk-in closet, and an updated bathroom featuring a soaking tub, a curb-less walk-in shower, and heated towel rack. This home also includes a massive amount of storage, a FROG which creates a bonus room/office adjacent to the primary suite, a central vacuum system, wiring for a backup generator, a huge three-bay garage, and a sound system with built-in speakers in the dining room, office, and patio room. Roof is 2017; with transferable warranty!

26 S Thrush Dr, Carlisle

Listing courtesy of Keller Williams of Central PA. Contact: (717) 761-4300

$1,285,000
5 Beds 4 Baths
Impeccably designed modern Colonial featured in Country Living magazine! Extraordinary opportunity to become only the second owners of this luxury property. The stunning details of this home need to be seen to be appreciated. The flooring is reclaimed random width pine repurposed from a barn in Connecticut, the windows are custom 9 over 9, one-of-a-kind sconces and light fixtures are abundant, the window candles are hardwired, and every single closet is oversized. Picture perfect, the kitchen is both stunning and functional complete with high-end finishes like solid wood cabinetry with inlaid doors, maple butcher block countertops, apothecary drawers, an appliance garage, double sink, under counter lighting, and built-in space for the fridge. The beamed ceiling adds to the richness of the space, and the peninsula was built to provide a spot for stools- a spot that is sure to become the best place for a quick meal or conversation while cooking. An entertainer’s delight, the kitchen is open to the keeping room that serves as the heart of this home. The custom built-ins and pantry provide storage while the double sided fireplace constructed with stones from the property add warmth and beauty. The dining space is awash with natural light and is built to seat over 40+ people! The living room sits on the other side of the fireplace and showcases a classic style with crown molding, chair rail detailing, and a wall of built-in shelving that is both beautiful and practical. The second staircase serves as a private entrance to your primary suite. Spacious and tranquil, the focal wall is not just unique with a custom brick fireplace, it is also functional with double closet space and even room for a TV. The amenities continue in the attached bath with double vanities, deep soaking tub with jets, and separate shower. Not to be outdone, each of the additional bedrooms are spacious, comfortably fitting a king bed. 2nd floor laundry, with a utility sink and space to fold and sort, is a luxury you will wonder how you lived without! There are thoughtful touches throughout the home that emphasize the designer’s touch: each bathroom in the house has a custom created vanity to look antique and fit the space, the hall bath on the second floor has a custom paint finish, and one bedroom has a welcoming window seat. Head downstairs to experience a finished lower level done right! The focal point of the space is undeniably the phenomenal wet bar complete with bottle storage, sink, and two-tiered sitting area. The open floor plan is elevated by sconce lighting, crown molding, and custom under stair shelving. The lower level bedroom and full bath are versatile and private- perfect for aging parents, older children, or even visitors. Looking for more amenities? Perfectly perched on a sprawling 5 acre lot, the spectacular outdoor living begins on the screened porch. The high-end detailing continues even here with a beadboard ceiling, double ceiling fans, and perfectly laid brick flooring. The sparkling in-ground 20x40 custom concrete and slate pool surrounded by a picket fence and herb garden is unlike anything you’ve ever seen. Every home needs good “bones” and this home boasts features meant for peace of mind including 400 amp service, geothermal heat, water softener, Bilco doors to the lower level, and double staircases. Unequalled, the detached garage is oversized in all the right ways. Each of the 3 bays accommodates any size vehicle. The surrounding space can be used for your tractor, RVs, bikes, and other toys. Even more opportunities for storage in the easily accessible 2nd floor of the garage. The driveway allows for easy overflow parking. The best kept secret about this home? It is only 20 years old! You will not find a more thoughtfully designed home with both modern amenities and unbelievable personality.

111 N Old Stonehouse Rd, Carlisle

Listing courtesy of Joy Daniels Real Estate Group, Ltd. Contact: (717) 695-3177

$549,000
5 Beds 3 Baths
HISTORY! HISTORY! HISTORY! Historic early 1800 Tavern, Inn and Principal Residence on 2.2 acres which wind down to a long frontage on Mt Rock Spring Creek. The original home was built in the mid-1700's while the current brick home dates to circa 1820. Along with the main structure, there is a large garage/barn, a log cabin which was moved piece by piece from a family property in Lurgan, smoke house, garden area, and inground swimming pool which has a new liner and new pump. All the pool equipment conveys with the property. The swimming pool is located above the grounds and is barely visible from the main structures so as to not take away from the essence of the grounds. The main house still has the Tavern room which can be excluded from the adjoining room dining room by large doors that pull down. The Tavern room still has the old bar, fireplace, wide board floors and candle candelabra. The kitchen has walk-in fireplace, which had been covered over, but the latest owner uncovered it and rebuilt it. When electricity was being installed in the kitchen, a hidden underground room with access from the kitchen via a trap door under the cabinets was discovered. Bricks are laid all around the room about 30" high and 3' across. There was a bucket on a pole with access to the cistern. Could this have been part of the underground railroad!? The entire property is full of intrique and is extremely unique. What an opportunity to own a piece of history! Opportunities like this are rare and so is the property! The main house consists of 3200 sq ft and has such great potential! Much more information about the history available upon request.

2799 Ritner Hwy, Carlisle

Listing courtesy of Coldwell Banker Realty. Contact: (717) 761-4800

$674,900
5 Beds 4 Baths
Back on market due to buyers change in circumstance. Welcome to 731 Appalachian Avenue, a modern and spacious retreat in Carlisle, PA. This stunning home boasts 5 bedrooms, 2 full bathrooms, 2 half bathrooms and a generous 3981 square feet of living space, all nestled on a sizable .35 acre lot. Step inside and be greeted by an inviting open floor plan that seamlessly connects the living, dining, and kitchen areas. The upgraded eat-in kitchen is a culinary delight, featuring granite countertops, stainless steel appliances, and ample storage space. The main level also hosts a cozy fireplace, perfect for creating a warm ambiance on chilly evenings. Venture downstairs to discover a fully finished basement, complete with a convenient wet bar and a half bathroom. With a walk-out entrance, this space offers endless possibilities for entertaining or relaxation. Each of the 4 bedrooms is thoughtfully designed, offering comfort and privacy for all. On the 2nd floor, you'll find a large laundry space complete with countertops and cabinets, providing convenience and efficiency for your daily tasks. Outside, the property provides a tranquil escape, with plenty of space for outdoor gatherings or simply unwinding in the fresh air. Don't miss the opportunity to make this remarkable property your own. Schedule a showing today and experience the allure of 731 Appalachian Avenue for yourself. Movement Mortgage is offering a free 1-year buy down of interest rate for any purchaser

731 Appalachian Ave, Carlisle

Listing courtesy of Compass Pennsylvania, LLC. Contact: (267) 435-8015

Start Your Search